'It’s What’s Inside' review: Twisty comedy pokes fun at inner beauty

Courtesy of Netflix

In the age of social media, appearances and optics are everything. This idea serves as the lynchpin of writer-director Greg Jardin’s twisty and inventive film “It’s What’s Inside.” Eerily reminiscent of “Bodies Bodies Bodies,” with a sci-fi twist I won’t spoil, the film provides a timely commentary on the impact of our online presence, the relentless pursuit of followers, and how our insecurities can lead us down irreversible paths of self-destructive confidence.

The story begins with the stunning yet insecure Shelby (Brittany O’Grady, known from the first season of “White Lotus”), who can’t stop doomscrolling on Instagram. Despite her efforts to spice things up in the bedroom, her boyfriend Cyrus (James Morosini) seems increasingly indifferent, leaving her to wonder if he’d prefer their blonde influencer friend from college, Nikki (Alycia Debnam-Carey).

This tension continues to simmer as the couple heads to a mansion party celebrating the marriage of their college friends Reuben (Devon Terrell) and Sophia (Ali Nordie), taking a detour from the traditional bachelor party route. Alongside the bride and groom, there’s Dennis (Gavin Leatherwood), the wealthy frat bro; Maya (Nina Bloomgarden), the free spirit; and Brooke (Reina Hardesty), who thrives on living dangerously. Of course, there’s also Nikki, the woman Shelby suspects Cyrus secretly desires. Although Cyrus insists he doesn’t, his eyes and body language tell a different story.

The setup is familiar: a college reunion in a secluded house, where interactions and side conversations are laden with subtext. Honest emotions are stifled, and past grudges resurface. Just as the tension escalates, an unexpected arrival shifts the evening’s trajectory. Forbes (David Thompson), an old friend, arrives with a mysterious suitcase, sending the night into chaos—a revelation I won’t disclose, as it reveals the film’s biggest twist.

The narrative raises important questions about self-love and the relationships we value. It explores what we truly want from our lives and who we deem worthy of our time and affection. While the film can be a bit self-indulgent and occasionally confusing—especially during the frenetic third act—Jardin’s colorful and zany filmmaking style keeps the momentum alive. It’s loud, vibrant, and solidly acted by an ensemble that harmonizes well, making it an ideal watch with a group of friends. Perhaps it will even inspire a game of “Mafia” or “Werewolf” afterward. Just remember to watch your back.

Grade: B

IT’S WHAT’S INSIDE is streaming now on Netflix